BEVERLY HILLS, CA — The school board race that turned a small city into a national headline is over. Beverly Hills voted to keep the direction it already had.
Two seats were on the Nov. 3 ballot for the Beverly Hills Unified School District Board of Education. For a district of five schools and roughly 3,000 students, the campaign drew a crowd.
Board President Judy Manouchehri won another term with 30.6% of the vote, or 6,870 ballots. The count came from the Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk on Nov. 10.
Attorney David Cienfuegos claimed the second seat with 26.6%, or 5,975 votes. He takes the chair being vacated by board member Rachelle Marcus.
Three candidates finished behind them. Attorney Jackie Kruger drew 20%, district parent Kim Lifschitz 16.7%, and teacher Jared Gonzales 6.1%.
The count remains unofficial while the county processes the last ballots. Certification is expected in early December, and the winners are set to be sworn in Dec. 15.
The tally, at a glance
- Judy Manouchehri (incumbent): 30.6% — 6,870 votes
- David Cienfuegos: 26.6% — 5,975 votes
- Jackie Kruger: 20% — 4,483 votes
- Kim Lifschitz: 16.7% — 3,739 votes
- Jared Gonzales: 6.1% — 1,366 votes
- Top two win. Swearing-in: Dec. 15. Certification: early December.
Source: Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk, Nov. 10 release (results unofficial).
A race the whole country watched
The contest was officially nonpartisan. It did not stay that way.
Manouchehri and Cienfuegos drew support from conservative figures and the Israeli-American Civic Action Network. Kruger and Lifschitz were backed by liberal groups, including the West Hollywood-Beverly Hills Democratic Club.
The campaign also carried ugly episodes — stolen signs, bruised group chats, antisemitism in parent forums. Reports landed in the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal.
Stolen signs were reported. Parent group chats turned on each other. A school district that normally debates bell schedules became a national proxy for something larger.
Turnout was not the story. The volume was.
For a city this small, the glare was strange. The fights were about school board seats, not storefronts on Rodeo.
At the board’s Nov. 10 meeting, the tension had a shelf life. Members offered congratulations and, in the same breath, exhaled.
“It was brutal, but I would say that the result was absolute,” board member Russell Stuart said. “It was an absolute mandate from the voters.”
Board member Amanda Stern was blunter about the process. “I’ve seen displays of great unkindness on both sides,” she said. “Campaign season just sucks.”
Down the street the same week, the City Council felt the ripples. Councilwoman Rebecca Pynoos said she was disappointed that the city’s disputes had drawn national ink at all.
Who is David Cienfuegos
The newcomer is not a stranger to the district. Cienfuegos is the parent of three students at Horace Mann Elementary, on Charleville Boulevard.
He ran as a parent first. His stated priorities are academic achievement, sensible use of technology in classrooms, campus safety, and fiscal discipline.
“I entered this race to strengthen our schools and expand opportunities for every student,” Cienfuegos said after the results. “I will serve with dedication, independence and an open mind.”
That word, independence, is doing some work. His seat gives the board a new voice at a moment when the district is still explaining its own progress.
Manouchehri, for her part, read the outcome as an endorsement. “However you voted, I invite you to come together as one Beverly Hills community,” she said.
I’m proud of the campaign we ran — grounded in truth and a record of undeniable achievement at BHUSD. Promises made. Promises kept.
— Board President Judy Manouchehri
He joins a board that includes Vice President Sigalie Sabag, Russell Stuart, Amanda Stern, and Manouchehri. Sabag offered the shortest summary of the season. “I’m glad it’s over,” she said.
Horace Mann sits on a leafy block a few minutes from the Golden Triangle. On a school morning, the sidewalk fills with strollers, scooters, and parents late for work.
The work the shouting interrupted
Away from the microphones, the district had a decent year to talk about.
Test scores rose at every school. The share of students meeting state standards climbed in math, in science, and in English Language Arts.
Beverly Hills High School, on Moreno Drive, posted double-digit gains in both English and math. The district laid the numbers out over the fall, and they hold up.
Those results are the context the new board inherits. The five campuses are the same set that anchors the district’s structure and numbers. The gains are detailed in the district’s most recent academic report.
The board’s job now is unglamorous. Budgets, bell schedules, campus safety plans. The kind of work that ends up in a consent agenda, not a headline.
The district’s own pages, at bhusd.org, carry the meeting agendas and the fuller record.
The district office on South Lasky Drive is where the unglamorous decisions land. The Beverly Hills Courier tracked the race from the first filing to the final count.
What happens next
The county certifies the results in early December. The board seats turn over on Dec. 15.
Two of the five seats will change hands. Three will not. The swearing-in lands two weeks before Christmas, mid–Rodeo Drive season, when the city is at its most photographed.
The campaign’s residue will not vanish with a swearing-in. Trust, once bruised in a group chat, does not heal on a schedule.
Until then, the same five members govern, and the last meeting of the year will run on muscle memory.
After that, a president who won comfortably and a freshman who promised independence have to agree on things. That is where campaigns go to become governance.
Beverly Hills likes a clean line, a nice facade, a story with a bow on it. School boards rarely offer one. They offer budgets and boundary maps and the slow arithmetic of a school year.
The national cameras have moved on. The parents on Charleville Boulevard have not.
At Horace Mann, the morning drop-off will look the same on Dec. 16 as it did on Nov. 2. Same line of cars. Same crossing guard. Same backpack dragging on the sidewalk.
What changed is the person one of those parents became: a school board member, sworn in the day before, still learning the acronyms.
The campaign is closed. The count is nearly certified. And in a city that measures itself in blocks, five schools just got a new hand on the wheel.
The real scoreboard starts in January.